CPAs vs. NON-CPAs


Certified Public Accountant (CPA)

In the United States a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) is a person who has been licensed by their State Board of Accountancy to practice public accounting The following article focuses on U.S. policy.  Other countries have equivalent accounting organizations, education standards, and other requirements for certification. For instance, Canada certifies accountants under two categories; (1) Certified General Accountants (CGA), and (2) Certified Management Accountants (CMA).   

CPAs vs. Independent Non-Certified Accountants

Essentially, non-certified accountants can simply hang up their shingle and open their doors for business.  For instance, there are three main types of financial statements that can be prepared by accountants: (1) audited, (2) reviewed, (3) compiled. 

Only a CPA can prepare an audited financial statement.  A report is then issued by the auditing accountants stating whether they found the information contained in the financial statements to be presented fairly, in all material respects.

In addition, only a CPA can prepare a reviewed financial statement. Both CPAs and non-certified accountants, including bookkeepers, can prepare compiled financial statements.  This means that, if you want to have your financial statements audited or reviewed, you must have a CPA perform that work.  Obviously, those services cost more than a compiled financial statement.  Most small businesses will never need to have their financial statements audited or reviewed.

Market conditions have brought on the use of non-certified accountants because, characteristically, CPAs charge more for their services than non-certified accountants and bookkeepers.  Many small business owners do. A non-certified accountant can prepare a simple financial statement that amply provides the information necessary to file a tax return.  In most cases, banks accept a compiled financial statement, prepared by an outside accountant, whether a CPA or not.

This has created the so called “turf battles” in some states between CPAs and non-certified accountants.  In California, there are approximately 20,000 non-certified, independent accountants.  There are expert CPAs and inexperienced CPAs.  Obviously, it is the same for non-certified accountants and bookkeepers. QUESTION:  Do I Need An Accountant?

Does your business needs an outside accountant?  If you require an audited or reviewed financial statement, then, yes, you need a CPA.  Whether your accountant is a CPA is up to you.  If you solely rely on your accounting staff or accountant for completely accurate financial data, then you are asking for trouble.  The language of business is accounting knowledge.

One scenario, if you can afford it, is to hire an internal accounting staff to prepare financial statements on a monthly basis and have an external accountant check them over.  There are numerous ways to work with an accountant.  Regardless, you should learn enough about accounting to be able to communicate intelligently with your accountant.  What does the accountant know about raw materials, work-in-process, and finished goods inventory accounting?  Perhaps a smaller firm with four or five accountants who are all seasoned veterans might work better.

Is your accountant too busy to talk to you?  Situations may arise where you need information immediately to make an important business or tax decision, will your accountant respond quickly? Billing practices vary from firm to firm.  For instance, an accountant might charge $200 a month to prepare a monthly financial statement but charge $100 an hour for special projects. >>>

(Summary by Oni Zamroni, from John W. Day, MBA)